Showing posts with label review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label review. Show all posts

Thursday, June 18, 2015

Taking Stock as a Photographer

What do you really want to photograph?

To answer that question, I spent last weekend in a workshop with Ana Puig Rosado, an amazing photographer who lives only 30 minutes' drive from me in the beautiful lavender valley of La Roche St Secret. This is my photo of her house, reflected in the window of a typical Provencal cabanon. She maintains two websites to separate her photo-journalism from her weddings and other projects. Both are stunning.

Fears that my French would let me down diminished as I discovered that 'RAW' is 'RAW' in French, pronounced 'Roe', evidemment. Camera settings and menus are all in English so it's my French friends who have to get used to S for Vitesse (or for Canon shooters TV, which I always think of as Toute Vitesse).

Ana travels. Sometimes commissioned, sometimes with a project she hopes to sell afterwards and sometimes because she just 'wants to go to Tel Aviv.' She is a photo-reporter, working usually with natural light and an emphasis on getting it right in camera. She is the antidote to stock photography, in which I've been semi-conditioned for the last 6 years. Her notion of editing is to choose a small selection of photos that make a coherent collection.

Here's the portfolio that Ana put together showing the workshop behind the scenes as well as mini-galleries from each of us (mine is the first one).  

Until recently, I saw each photo as a one-off. Albums were 'best of'. Influenced by reading David DuChemin, I have started to think about collections as a whole, in the galleries on my website; in the selection chosen with my Editor for 'One Sixth of a Gill'. You can imagine how pleased I was with the reviews from the Wishing Shelf judges; 'A worthy finalist... 5 (of the 31) judges thought that the photography was the best part.' It is time to ask more of myself as a photographer.
If you'd like a free copy of 'One Sixth of a Gill' please sign up here for my newsletter.

With perfect timing, I received a professional report on the portfolio from LensCulture, whose portrait competition I'd entered. By happenstance, this is also the organisation which featured Dead Season on the Edge of the Black Sea by - guess who - Ana Puig Rosado! Some things are just meant to be.

The opportunity to receive a review was given as a bonus for entry and I was asked to submit a portfolio of 10 photos. I chose the 3 portraits I'd entered for the competition (that hadn't won) and 7 others I liked, showing the range of my work.


Don't cheat. look at these photos and decide what feedback you would give. Then read what I was told. 




Reviewer Feedback

I found some of these individual images very interesting and was drawn in by your innovative approach to self-portraiture. The mix of work here is very eclectic. I can understand it is hard to summarize your work in one edit and you may have wanted to demonstrate the depth and breadth of your practice, but I suppose we are just very used to seeing series of work in photography where you see one body of work explored in-depth. There are many images here that are very singular and beautifully taken shots particularly image 5 and 6. But I would encourage you to move from picking an individual good image to thinking about your work as a series.

Editing into a coherent series would enable the viewer to see more of you and how you work and also what you have to say. As we are so saturated by images all the time we need to work out what we are looking at and how to position it easily. I notice you do not have an artist's statement. It might be a very helpful exercise for you to write one. I realise they are hard to do as they in part require you to be concise and clear about what you are doing and you may work in a more organic less premeditated way. But the advantage is they force you to consider what might connect your work, and help you to develop confidence in your own voice.

Perhaps that is why the self-portraits interest me, they tell me more about you ( I am assuming they are of you). They make me think of Bill Viola's moving and slow studies of faces which take on a religious or spiritual edge and are very powerful. I like the idea that a single fixed image of self is never enough. We change so much over time and expressions alter our faces completely and you capture this well with this group of 3 images. I hope you will continue with those more in the future.

What do I think of the review?

I'm chuffed! And I smile now at my naivete in putting the collection together in such a random way. I'm writing this blog for everybody who's shared in my progress as a photographer - and for others who still think of one photo at a time.

Compliments like those in the review are really motivating me to carry on experimenting without worrying about what will sell in my istockphoto portfolio. 

Thank you to that anonymous reviewer, who made further suggestions. I would love comments from other photographers on the blog, on the review, on the idea of collections. I haven't answered the question of what I really want to photograph but I have some ideas!

Monday, February 4, 2013

Don't stalk your readers!

The classic scenario:-

Bestselling author is stalked by psychopathic reader, who stakes out the author's house and sets physical traps, which the writer narrowly escapes. Moral; fans can be nutters - writers beware!

The modern version:-

Honest reader, who's written a negative review, is stalked online by psychopathic, self-published wannabe-writer, who pursues the hapless reviewer through blog and readers' groups. Moral; writers can be nutters - readers beware!

I want to meet you
Unfortunately, the modern version is all too real, a consequence of the new publishing world in which writer and reader can tweet and pinterest. I've blogged already about the democratisation of the review; nowadays Fred Bloggs' review on amazon is as useful to an author's ranking, if not more so, as James Joyce's review in 'The Times Literary Supplement'. Ranking improves visibility; visibility leads to sales. Some writers are willing to do anything - and I mean anything! - to get ahead in the modern goldrush, hoping to become ebook millionaires. The short time I spent on Harper Collins authonomy site (and blogged about here) horrified me, not just by showing what the writers were willing to do, but also what publishers actively encourage as 'marketing'. Spam and gang bullying, multiple screen persona to review your own books - the seedy underbelly of self-promotion is like some kind of crazy presidential race, corrupting all who join in.

In the last week, I've come across two true stories of readers who've been harrassed by authors to such a degree that one made formal complaint to the website administration and the other has closed his blog completely to reviews. There has been no action from the website admin; instead, the reader is the one affected, avoiding contact.

Both these readers have cut off contact with writers and are adamant that self-published authors are more likely to bully readers if they don't like reviews than are conventionally published authors. Whether this is true or not, it is very bad press for self-published authors and I'm hoping this blog post will make writers think twice before chasing after a bad review. Just the thought of a writer bullying a reader and challenging his freedom of speech makes me very angry! So much more angry than a bad review of one of my books would make me!

The bullies won't take any notice but there are writers being sucked into this marketing craziness, who don't mean to cause the upset they do; these are the writers I'd like to reach. Please don't contact someone who's given you a bad review. You won't change the review; you will lose the reviewer, and not just for your own books.

Remember that any review is better than none; I just read some interesting data suggesting that readers like to see a few reviews for a book. They feel comfortable buying such a book, even if the reviews are negative. If the reviews are controversial as well as negative - great! That's called publicity! You can make mileage out of it and quote negative reviews - elsewhere, and not in an attack on the reviewer.

Over the last fortnight, I've had my first experience of tweeted reviews on one of my books. I was lucky and 'Song at Dawn' found a reader who loved the book, so it was a pleasure to read the tweets. However, I did wonder how I would have felt if the tweets had been negative. It would have hurt, for sure, and I wouldn't have re-tweeted! But I can't even imagine 'going after' the reviewer! The freedom to be critical is what makes praise valuable; one without the other is meaningless.

Not only was it a pleasure to read the 'Song' review tweets, it was an education. There is a world of fanfiction out there that I know nothing about. Thanks to a lot of work by one reader, there is now a fun page of TVTropes about 'Song at Dawn' and I am amazed at how much fun people can have with books - and should have with books. If this particular reader had been put off self-published books by badly-behaved writers, none of this fun would have happened.

Don't stalk readers - respect them. Don't turn into their worst nightmare.

Nightmare man





Tuesday, November 27, 2012

Win a rip-roaring 17thC adventure book


Knox Robinson Publishing
see amazon uk page here

WIN A SIGNED HARDCOVER COPY OF

THE CHOSEN MAN

ISBN 978 1 908483 24 9

To celebrate the release of the paperback edition of The Chosen Man on the 6th December, 2012, J.G. Harlond is running a promotional competition on her website.
Click on: www.jgharlond.name

Go to 'Competition' on the home page.

Click on 'Read'.

Read the chapter then answer the questions that follow.

Email answers to: jgharlond@telefonica.net

Deadline for receiving answers: 20th December, 2012
The lucky winner will be selected from those submitting the correct answers on 24th December, 2012.
J.G. Harlond will contact the winner for his/her home address via email.

J.G. Harlond - about the author



THE CHOSEN MAN

J.G. Harlond

It is 1635, Ludovico da Portovenere, a charismatic spice and silk merchant, is on a routine voyage from Constantinople to Amsterdam, but his voyage is interrupted; first by a timid English priest with a message from Rome then by a storm, and then by a pirate raid. Ludo’s plans are disrupted, as are the lives of the innocent people unwittingly entangled in his secret commission.


MY Review of 'The Chosen Man'


fun and full of energy; an entertaining read

Imagine Jack Sparrow working for the Vatican to break the Dutch economy by boom-and-bust selling of tulips; and a 17th century Spanish Lara Croft sorting out an English stately home with incidental husband and resident villain. This novel is fun and full of energy; black comedy abounds. The wide-ranging historical background is also very intelligent and well-informed, while in no way slowing down the swashbuckling story.


The slow-burning romance between the two lively main characters, Ludo the loveable rogue, and Alina, the feisty Spanish girl stranded in a foreign country, adds to the enjoyment. However, the two plots are otherwise very separate and this makes for some disjointed storytelling, with awkward jumps in viewpoint.



I've read 'Tulip Fever' so knew some of the historical background, and was expecting this to be heavy,depressing and political, especially in our time of 'financial crisis'. Not a bit of it! I found `The Chosen Man' to be a very entertaining read and I would definitely read another novel by this author.

Thursday, December 22, 2011

Democracy and book reviews - yours matter



Are you more likely to buy a book if it is recommended by

a) a household name superstar?
b) a well-known author/journalist?
c) your friend?
d) an unknown online reviewer/Blogger?
e) a lot of people online?

I have only just realised how my own habits as a reader are changing, so of course I am thinking about what this means for me as a writer.

In life before computers, I used to read book reviews in newspapers, and I also used to notice the quotations on a book's cover. If I liked Writer X and Writer X said 'The best historical novel this year' I'd give the book a try. I would also share book recommendations with friends who had similar reading tastes. So that puts the former me firmly in b) and c)

I'm still a c) person but I've ditched b) not just because I no longer read newspapers, not just because I'm cynical about the small mutual appreciation societies of the successful, but because I read reviews online, wherever they catch my eye. The big sites for me are amazon and goodreads but I also read reviews on smashwords and on online journals. Surely online journals are just a modern version of those newspapers of the past? Not so. There were perhaps a dozen newspapers for sale and not all of those had book reviews. Even if you add magazines, the number of publications was tiny compared with the explosion of online material. More publications and more reviewers, destroying that little clique of the past - or creating a million new little cliques, depending how you see things.

If I read a well-written review that tells me something about the book and gives a judgement on it that makes sense, I am definitely influenced. If I see ten such reviews, the book stays in my mind as one to read. d) and e) are becoming far more important and the only criterion for me is that the review itself tells me what I need to know. I don't care who the reviewer is, where he lives, how successful she is at her job - all I care about is the information on a book I might want to read. All that matters in a reviewer is the reading, and the reviewing. Democracy at work!

I know that authors are supposed to 'persuade' friends and family to write reviews, or sign up under pseudonyms and write their own. Apart from the difficulties thrown in their way by the book sites, this strategy has another disadvantage - you can tell if a review is phony. I can certainly tell. So as far as I'm concerned, if the review does its job I don't care whether it's written by the author or his granny, it's telling me what I want to know about the book. Comparing two reviews will usually show up a phony one.

Although I'm very grateful when friends or family like one of my books and post a review, I don't ask. I prefer to keep my friends and family rather than have them avoid me because a) I'll expect them to buy my latest book - 14 books cost a lot of money b) I'll want them to do homework on it after reading it.

I find myself writing more and more reviews because I know how much it matters, to the writer and to other readers. If I buy something on ebay, I leave feedback. It keeps ebay safe. If I read a book and take 2 minutes to star-rate it on goodreads, it keeps the book industry democratic. I have the right to vote; I should use it. Gone are the days when some white man in a public-school tie praised the work of some other white man in a public-school tie (or of course, trashed it, because that too can be part of the review game)

If you've read something you loved, say so and why. If you've read something you hated, say so and why. Your vote counts.